Ink Inc.

Preference and Discrimination

Posted in Personal, Unfettered by lovelyloey on August 16, 2008

Yesterday we were discussing the topic of preference and discrimination in class. I was recounting a story to Su and XP about how I was at a Suntec City toilet when this mother with her 4-year-old (thereabout) son was in the line. I overheard the boy saying something like “the flower one fatty bom bom” (I was wearing a shirt with flower prints that day.). Not only that, he went on saying “fatty bom bom, bom bom bom, bom bom bom …” as though it was amusing. Frankly speaking, it was amusing, even though I was the object of insult. I knew the boy was being rude, but I couldn’t be arsed to do anything about it. Because if I had said anything, it would have meant (1) I admit it was me, aka. I think I am a fatty bom bom myself; (2) I am being intolerant towards guileless young children; (3) I am generally a nasty person. So I ignored the child. His lack of manners obviously stems from something else. The mother did not stop him, which adequately shows how much respect SHE has for other people (i.e. me). So if I had tried to say anything, how would such a parent retaliate? Or deflect the accusation by feigning ignorance? Get me right, I am not condoning the act, but I took a step back and decided not to act because I gave the issue some thought: (1) this is ill upbringing, which is something I can’t be arsed to interfere with, because without insensitive asses like these, there are no GOOD people in this world (relatively, of course.) (2) A child with ill manners will never make it big in life anyway, so that’s good enough justice. (3) Stealing a quote from a friend, I only have endure this lousy attitude for 5 minutes, the child and his parents will have to endure it for a lifetime. Aw. So sad right? Now, don’t chide me for having vengeful thoughts and being mentally evil, that is my right as a thinking creature.

Anyway, back to the topic on preference and discrimination. At the end of the discussion we sort of came to an agreement that it’s a very thin line between what’s preference and what’s discrimination. The rationale is that, when you use a certain variable (e.g. physical attributes) as a basis to judge another variable (e.g. work performance), you are discriminating. For example, guy A abhors fat women. In being the boss of a radio station, he admits a twiggy DJ over a fat DJ,even though they both have equal qualifications. That is discrimination because size is not a relevant nor justified basis of rejection here. However, the tricky part comes when it’s choosing a romantic partner. if I said I preferred rich men, and so refuse to go out with this poor fella, is that discriminating? I don’t think the crux lies in whether the choice is rationally justifiable, but then again I’m not sure what makes it NOT a discrimination then. So there’s that thin line between preference and discrimination.

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. sulz said, on August 16, 2008 at 10:03 am

    i posted something along this line a while back, but i can’t find that post haha. anyway, yes, there is a very fine line between preference and discrimination. preference is probably a form of discrimination. like for example, i’m a well-known chocoholic. so if i were to choose cakes of ice cream, i’d always go for the chocolate kind, even if the place is famous for cheesecake or some rainbow sherbet flavoured ice cream. which is kinda discriminatory to cheesecake and rainbow sherbet, right? i haven’t even tried them but i still choose chocolate. how would i know if the chocolate is better than cheesecake or rainbow sherbet??

    but i memang love chocolate mar! so is that preference or discrimination?

    For your case, it’s preference. You only cross the line when you start saying things like people who like cheesecake ice cream are stupid, or people who don’t like chocolate ice cream are stupid. In that you make your personal preference of ice cream be a basis of judging someone?
    We ARE entitled to our irrational preferences (like I don’t like bittergourd and I will never try it). But when you extend this irrational preference as a rational reason for something else, that’s just a bit wrong. hmm.

  2. sulz said, on August 17, 2008 at 6:35 am

    wah, okay. expert speak oh. haha.

    Haha, just saying la. Not expert. LOL.

  3. denise said, on August 18, 2008 at 12:27 pm

    actually i doubt you should (or could) have done anything. we can’t control what parents teach their kids, be it racism or sexism or sizism. i only draw the line if they hurt other people according to their prejudices.

    Yeah, that’s why I didn’t even want to tell her that her child is rude, since she probably taught him that. :)


Leave a Reply